It is very rare these days to meet a manager who hasn't
been involved in at least one attempt to change an organization's
culture. If you have, then you'll realize that it isn't as
easy as many executives think, and there are readily available
guidelines to help us through the process that are often
ignored. This short article outlines one guideline that is
often a missing and very important piece of the puzzle.
Let's start with a two part question; part one is "How
long does it take to change an organizational culture?" Part
two is "How long is a piece of string?". What both
these questions have in common is that they are impossible
to answer without lots more information. The time it will
take to change a culture depends on the breadth and depth
of the desired change. It depends on the size of the organization.
It also depends on a judgement of when has the culture has
actually changed. Is it when a critical mass of employees
have adopted the new culture, or when every single employee
does? Since the world is always changing, so too is the need
to change culture, so is there ever a point at which you
can say, we've reached the
ideal culture?
For those who have
been through an attempt at changing culture, one thing will
have become obvious. The transition will come quicker and
easier if management know and follow the well-tested principals
of culture change. Experience has shown that successful change
can take one of two paths. Management can take the long path
to change, which is to dive in without careful planning and
background knowledge, take a lot of missteps, but persist
long enough and eventually make the transition. Or they can
take a shorter path, which is to use the principals of change
that we have learned through many years of such initiatives,
make fewer mistakes, and arrive at the destination far earlier.
This article is more relevant to those taking the shorter
path. Suppose the organization takes the time to develop
clear, realistic transition goals. Also suppose they are
fortunate enough to have an executive group with experience
and knowledge of the transition process. They may use a consultant
to guide them, but the executive take full responsibility
for the success or failure of the process. Even in such a
positive scenario we often see a piece of the transition
puzzle missing, and it's an important piece. Let me describe
a typical missing-piece scenario.
The executive team identifies
the costs and lost opportunities that are a result of elements
of their existing culture that haven't kept pace with the
changing world. They make a firm decision to change, and
identify specific elements that must change. They develop
change goals and a vision of what things will look like when
the change is successful. They develop a strategic transition
plan that is well thought out and based on success stories
in other organizations. They communicate the plan for change
and start implementation by, amongst other steps, aligning
organizational systems and processes with their change goals.
They then start to push the plan down the organization, level
by level. So what have they missed?
We call the approach
described above the "cascade down" approach to
change. It consists of a transition plan made by senior management
and cascaded down the organization from one level to the
next. The problem with this is that cultural change just
doesn't happen that way. Change progresses in a "pockets
of success" way. Some individuals and departments adopt
change readily and become early pockets of success. Some
procrastinate and require convincing while others resist.
So if you accept this rationale, then it follows that change
happens more efficiently if the focus becomes finding ways
to quickly build pockets of success. And this will happen
if individual managers take charge of the process and start
their own transition, one guided by the overall direction
developed by senior management.
Now we come to the missing
piece. Departments will more readily become pockets of success
to the extent that middle and first level supervisors and
managers know the steps of successful culture change. Very
few organizations even attempt to pass this knowledge down;
senior management believing that "they don't need to
know this, because we're responsible for the change process".
We've been fortunate enough to work on several culture change
projects in which we've convinced clients to give all managers
the knowledge required to plan change at their level. We've
found it benefits in two ways. First, middle and lower levels
of management, rather than blindly following management direction,
have a greater understanding of why senior management are
taking the steps they're taking. Secondly, these managers
can go back to their departments and become mini-engines
of change, and early pockets of success.
For those interested,
Touchstone publishes a book entitled "Make Change Work" which
is designed for middle and first level managers and has been
successfully used as pre-reading for Culture Change Workshops
designed for these employees.
For more information
contact Bob
Power |